
The classroom can be an actual rulebook, but some rules are a bit shocking.
From banning red ink to strict timers for recess — today’s American schools are imposing new rules and regulations. These rules are often mentioned in district emails and teacher meetings, and many people aren’t convinced they actually help students learn. As these rules are adopted, teachers come up with innovative ways to adjust, question, or even gently violate the guidelines.
A color that is tested

It might sound ridiculous, but whether teachers are allowed to grade work with red ink is a subject of serious debate. Research suggests that red marks can be more abrasive, affecting how students perceive their work. However, the rules differ. Some principals recommend green or purple instead. An elementary school English teacher explained, "I use red for final grades, but switch to teal on drafts so it's less scary."
Red ink isn’t a crime by law. Many teachers personalize their teaching approach and balance clear feedback with softer colors.
Required play — The 30-minute recess instruction
Certain states, such as Washington, are now requiring children to take 30 minutes of outside play every day. The idea? Get children moving — just like the CDC recommends. Teachers often support more physical activity, but now find themselves squeezed into already busy schedules. “Between drills and assemblies, every new rule takes time from something else,” says a Texas fourth grade teacher.
The "empathy lesson" and Social-Emotional Learning
Many schools now offer weekly Social-Emotional Learning (SEL) classes. The goal is to aid with self-awareness and kindness. A RAND schools survey shows almost all schools schedule a half-hour for empathy; however, lessons could be reduced. The SEL topic has sparked debate, with some critics calling them hidden politics.
"We're told exactly which color to grade with, but no one asks how to help kids actually understand photosynthesis."
Math policy — Rethinking when to take Algebra
California’s revised Math Framework prohibits students from taking Algebra I early, aiming for a more equitable math curriculum. Some critics worry this will leave students less prepared for advanced math. In contrast, only 26 percent of U.S. eighth-grade students — according to recent data — mark themselves as “proficient” in math, causing concern throughout the country.
Rules: why do they increase?
Every new policy is intended to improve outcomes, but their accumulation can signal distrust. Teachers know how these regulations affect morale, especially when they dictate details like ink color but leave out the most important thing: real learning. National survey data shows this pressure is a reason teachers leave early in their careers.
Checklist: Common K-12 directives teachers will see
- Use purple or green pen instead of the red ink
- Ensure 30 minutes of recess every day
- Give a weekly SEL "empathy" block
- Delay Algebra I until ninth grade
Teachers respond with innovative ways
Some teachers gently alter the rules, editing with soft colors, reserving red for major feedback, or mixing science lessons with recess. Others are more vocal in public forums. Most agree that teaching is best when there’s flexibility, not just a one-size-fits-all model.
The question of understanding why teachers quit so quickly is part of a larger story — one of exhausted educators who face increasing rules that don’t always provide students what they truly need.
Comments